A Case of Conscience
by Isabel C. Clarke
Published in 1927 by Benziger Brothers
370 pages
Review of A Case of Conscience:
In this highly readable and entertaining novel by Isabel C. Clarke, the plot does indeed revolve around issues of conscience. What do you do when your conscience seems to stand in the way of what your heart desires? This novel deals with love, vocations, keeping the faith, and mixed marriages–all without preaching or being heavy-handed.In nineteen-year-old Elizabeth’s case, she falls in love with Timothy, but she must guard this fact so as not to come between him and her half-sister Opal. As a fervent Catholic, however, Elizabeth cannot in good conscience support the idea of Timothy marrying outside of the Church, as Opal’s family demands. Thus Elizabeth is put in an awkward position. She already feels unwanted by her mother (who left Elizabeth as a baby and abandoned the Faith). The animosity is increased when Elizabeth’s mother accuses Elizabeth of driving a wedge between Timothy and Opal for her own selfish benefit.
In Timothy’s eyes, Opal is a vision, an enchanting beauty, all he’s ever wanted–he only wishes she’d see how important his faith has become since his visit to Italy, which awakened him to his previously lax ways. Yet Timothy is convinced he cannot be happy without Opal. He cannot give her up an any cost. He is given an ultimatum by Opal’s imposing father. What can Timothy do when love and the Catholic faith are at such odds? How can he choose one and forsake the other?
Finally, there’s Opal, the stunning beauty raised as a wealthy and spoilt only child. She’s captured Timothy’s heart. She wants to marry him, but can’t go against her Father, whom she adores and yet who decrees that the two cannot marry in the Catholic Church. (Her mother and father hate the Catholic Church, for reasons revealed in their history.) Opal thinks Timothy is being stubborn over a silly “scruple,” and if he truly loved her, he’d make this little sacrifice and marry outside the Church.
The characters are richly and deftly written so that they strike the reader as vivid and real. Description is well-done without being overdone. The story moves at a fine pace, with new turns of events keeping the reader’s interest. This novel with a conscience is highly recommended for high school students and young adults alike.
To give you a glimpse inside the book, here is an exchange between Timothy and Elizabeth, from page 159:
He stood alone, defending a lost hope, a forlorn position.
“If I hadn’t gone to Italy–” he said suddenly.
“You must be glad, not sorry that you went,” she said softly, with kindling eyes.
“Elizabeth, you’re a little saint, but you’re only fit for the cloister, not for this hard work-a-day materialistic world! Didn’t you ever want anything you oughtn’t to want and that you knew it would be bad for you to have if you could only get it by going against the Church?”
His shining blue eyes sought her face with an almost painful scrutiny. But in its grave unchanging pallor it offered no indication of emotion.
“Lots of times, Timothy. You mustn’t think life is any easier for me than for you.”
As she spoke she visualized Timothy and Opal standing side by side just as she had seen them on that first evening of her arrival in London, when it had seemed to her that they possessed all the gifts that human beings could possibly desire. They were young and beautiful, they loved each other. And while she looked at them she felt that her heart had been pierced by a sword . . . .”